Welcome to the Blog!

I Like Myself Better Now

I was walking toward the staging area of the parade, trying to find my group after being dropped off in the busy downtown crowd. Near the Cathedral Basilica of St. Peter in Chains, I noticed a gathering.

A man’s voice carried over a loudspeaker: “Holy Mary, pray for us sinners…”

The prayers were unfamiliar to me, but the intention was not. A group of men stood together, some holding flags, some holding beads, gathered beside a congregation of much more colorful flags and beads.

I was there to dance with the Shakers in the Cincinnati Pride Parade - something I never would have done just a few years ago.

In 2000, Brian and I went door-to-door in California to canvass for Proposition 22, the ballot measure that defined marriage as between one man and one woman. The church had sent letters asking members to give their time and resources to help ensure its success. It was an enormous effort and effective.

At the time, I believed I was doing what was right. If someone had asked whether I liked who I was, I would have said a confident “yes.” I was on the right path. I cared about the eternal happiness of my fellow beings. I was following God. I was being faithful and obedient. I was a good person, standing up for the truth and for what He wanted.

My life fit the narrative I had been taught was good and right: I identified as female, I was attracted to men, and my experience aligned with the church’s expectations and what I had been taught since infancy.

I saw homosexuality as a “personal struggle.” I believed people who experienced same-sex attraction had been given a particular trial in life. We all had trials, I thought, and theirs was to remain faithful, resist temptation, and not act on those feelings. I believed they could live a good life if they stayed focused and obedient - and even that they could be “healed” or “fixed” if they were faithful enough.

I had the scripture in Ether ingrained in me: God gives us weakness so that we may be humble, and Christ’s grace is sufficient so that weak things can become strong. This characteristic, I believed, was a weakness that could be changed.

I had not spent much time around people who were openly and outwardly honest about being gay. There were whispers about the man at church who seemed especially creative or flamboyant, or stories about close relatives who were gay, or others in our circle who had left heterosexual marriages because they did not seem to fit the life they were expected to live.

The volume of those messages was hushed, but their impact was loud.

This lifestyle, I was taught, carried sin and shame. I remember my dad saying, “God created Adam and Eve, not Adam and Steve.” And because my gender and sexuality aligned with that, I didn’t have a reason to question it. I fit. I belonged. I was acceptable.

Like most changes in perspective, mine did not happen all at once. It shifted through small interactions and growing understanding. A woman I ministered to had a child who identified as LGBTQ+, and she distanced herself from activity in the church. I did not understand that. I thought it must somehow be possible to reconcile her love for her child with church teachings. There had to be a middle ground where it could all be okay. Maybe her faithfulness would actually bless her child. 

Even then, I held tightly to the idea that I could “love the sinner, hate the sin.”

Then my own children began sharing how they wanted to live freely and fully in the world as themselves.

It was a shock to my system. But it was also surprisingly peaceful. I watched my children love who they were, and I knew they needed to feel loved by their mom.

I began to reason that homosexuality was not a trial for individuals at all. It was just a natural part of life. God wants us to be full of energy and light. It is difficult to live in that fullness when we are carrying shame and guilt for who we are. Maybe the trial in life belonged to those of us in more socially accepted relationships. Maybe the question was not whether they could overcome who they were, but how I would treat people who were different from me—people I had been taught were flawed, defective, or in need of fixing.

Would I merely tolerate them? Or would I embrace them? This was the trial.

My love for my children and the church teachings were once again in conflict. The question I had been able to hold in tension became increasingly difficult to answer during my temple recommend interviews:

Do you support or promote any teachings, practices, or doctrine contrary to those of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints?

It was easier when I only had to answer that question every two years instead of annually. For a while, I could somehow still hold both. I know this must have been difficult for my children and others during that time, and I am deeply grateful for their grace as I evolved and questioned everything I had ever been taught.

In October 2024, I found myself at another parade: the Cincinnati Blink Parade. This time, I was in the middle of my LDS deconstruction.

I had already told Brian I was leaving the church, and I was still figuring out who I was outside of it. I began looking at the world and everyone in it with wide-open, childlike eyes. Instead of asking, What does the handbook say about that? What do the scriptures say about that? I began asking, What do I think about that?

I was learning to listen to myself. To lean into curiosity. To trust.

Preston and I had been invited to participate in this fantastic parade with a group from GiGi’s Playhouse, an organization that supports people with Down syndrome. We gathered before the parade, covering ourselves in neon paint and lights.

Many families were joining together, but one stood out to me in particular: two fathers and their three small children, one of whom had Down syndrome.

I remember noticing the physical sensations move through my body: discomfort, curiosity, judgment, gratitude, wonder, ease. Then, as I watched them together, something shifted. I asked myself, How do I really feel about this? How do I want to feel about this?

And then there was no judgment. Only acceptance - and even respect.

Not tolerance for someone else’s “personal choices,” but admiration and adoration for a family loving one another openly and fully.

As we walked the parade route, there were smiles and cheers from the crowds and participants all around us. Drones flew overhead in a beautiful display. No one could see the celebration happening inside my heart, but I felt it.

I felt more alive. More loving. More myself than ever before.

Life felt easy. Other people felt easy.

I liked myself better in that space.

I liked who I was when there was no war in my heart between my values and someone else’s life. No need to be a good example. No need to be kind and friendly while still holding people at a distance because the church did not approve and because I might have to answer for my appreciation of this beautiful family.

There was nothing to protect.

And that brings me back to the Pride Parade, having the time of my life among joyful, accepting, loving expressions. There is openness. There is comfort. There is freedom.

I like myself even better now.

Why? Because I no longer need someone else to fit a certain narrative in order to be worthy of love and joy in this life. I can trust myself to be fully and authentically me, and I can offer that same trust to others - to be fully and authentically themselves.

I do not have to judge others in order to feel better about myself.

I love that I can rejoice in the fun and truth that feel innate to our souls: the beauty of deep connection to ourselves and to one another. My heart is bigger now. There is more space.

I do not have to spend my time and energy fasting and praying for people to see and change their wicked ways. I am tending instead to my own alignment with life, light, and love.

And I am peaceful.

Yes, I liked myself then.

But I like myself even better now.

File this under:

This space holds my writing as I navigate becoming. Through faith and unraveling, through travel and wild places, and through practices that bring me back into alignment. These are stories of my lived life: what I’m learning, where I’ve been, what I’m letting go of, and what I’m choosing to move toward.

Quick links

© Rachel Egbert.com